2341 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart Centre Mon–Fri 9–6 · Sat 9–5

When is it time to replace your hearing aids?

The answer

It is usually time to replace hearing aids when repairs keep piling up, parts are getting hard to find, your hearing has changed beyond what the devices can be programmed for, or you want features they cannot offer. Before replacing anything, rule out the cheaper fixes first: a cleaning, a new part, or reprogramming often solves it.

Hearing aids do not come with an expiration date. They wear out gradually, and the signs are easy to blame on something else. This guide walks through the practical signs it is time for a new pair, and the far more common case where the device just needs some attention. If you are already leaning toward a repair, our repairs and service page covers what we fix and how.

We will say this up front, because it is the most useful thing in the guide: most hearing aids that “stopped working” do not need replacing.

Start with the cheap fixes

Before you price new hearing aids, rule these out. They are the usual culprits, and none of them requires a new device.

  • Wax and moisture. Earwax blocks wax guards and receivers, and humidity gets into the electronics. A hearing aid that sounds weak, muffled or dead is very often just clogged.
  • Worn small parts. Domes perish, tubing hardens and yellows, and wax guards need regular changing. These are cheap parts, and a fresh set can make an old aid sound new again.
  • Settings drift. Your hearing shifts over the years, and the programming that suited you at the fitting may not suit you now. Reprogramming is often all it takes.
  • Battery issues. A bad battery, a dirty battery contact or a rechargeable aid sitting badly in its charger can all look like a dead hearing aid.

At Schmidt’s, cleanings and adjustments are free for as long as you own your hearing aids, whichever brand they are and wherever you bought them. That makes these fixes the obvious first step. If the free fix works, you have saved yourself the cost of a new pair.

Sign 1: repairs are piling up

One repair is normal. A repair every few months is a pattern. If you are sending the same aid out again and again, or several things are failing at once, each repair buys less time than the last. At some point the running total of repair bills is better spent on a device that works reliably.

A useful question: if this repair goes well, how long do you expect the aid to last before the next one? If the honest answer is “not long,” it may be time to stop.

Sign 2: parts are getting hard to find

Manufacturers move on to new models, and eventually the parts for older ones become scarce. When a repair needs a part that is no longer easy to get, the repair can take longer, cost more, or not be possible at all.

If you are told your model is getting difficult to service, take that seriously. It is better to plan a replacement on your own schedule than to have the aid fail before a family trip with no part available.

Sign 3: your hearing has changed beyond what the aid can do

Every hearing aid is built to cover a certain range of hearing loss. Within that range, it can be reprogrammed as your hearing changes. Outside it, it cannot.

If you find yourself turning the volume all the way up, still struggling with speech in conversations you used to follow, or relying more and more on captions, it is worth having your hearing checked. A free screening tells us whether your current aids can be adjusted to match your hearing now, or whether you have moved past what they were designed for. If they can be adjusted, we will adjust them.

Sign 4: power is fading

With disposable batteries, the battery door, contacts and internal wiring all wear over time. If fresh batteries are not lasting as long as they used to, or the aid cuts in and out, something inside may be failing.

Rechargeable hearing aids have their own version of this. The built-in cell holds less charge as it ages, so an aid that used to last all day may start running out by evening. Sometimes the real culprit is a dirty charger or contact, and sometimes it means the device is near the end. Either way, it is worth having it looked at rather than living with an aid that dies at dinner.

Sign 5: you want something your aids cannot do

This is a perfectly good reason, and you do not need to feel guilty about it. Newer hearing aids can offer things older ones may not:

  • Bluetooth streaming from your phone or television
  • Rechargeable batteries instead of tiny disposable ones
  • Better performance in noisy places like restaurants
  • Styles that are easier to handle if your fingers are not as nimble as they were

If your current aids work but do not fit the way you live now, replacing them is a lifestyle choice, not a failure. Our hearing aids page covers the different styles and what each is good at.

When it is not the hearing aid at all

Some changes are not a device problem and should not be treated as one. See a doctor promptly if you notice any of these:

  • Your hearing changed suddenly
  • Hearing is worse in one ear, or you hear ringing in only one ear
  • Ear pain, discomfort, or fluid or blood coming from the ear
  • Dizziness or a spinning feeling

The FDA (opens in a new tab) lists warning signs like these as reasons to see a doctor, preferably an ear, nose and throat specialist. Schmidt’s staff are licensed hearing aid specialists, not doctors, and a new hearing aid is not the answer to a medical question.

The honest part

Hearing aids are a real expense, and replacing them is not always the right call. If your aids still fit your hearing, the problem is one part, and they do what you need, repair them and keep wearing them. A clean, well-adjusted older aid often beats a new one you were talked into before you needed it.

We would rather tell you that than sell you a pair. If a repair is the better answer, we will say so.

How to decide, without pressure

The simplest way to find out is to bring your hearing aids in. We service any brand, wherever you bought them, and cleanings and adjustments are free. If they can be made to work, we will make them work.

If it does turn out to be time, start with a free screening so the new aids are fit to your hearing as it is today. A pair of digital hearing aids at Schmidt’s starts at $1,499, or $749.50 each. CareCredit financing is available, and FSA and HSA funds apply. And before you buy from anyone, it is worth reading what Florida’s 30-day hearing aid trial actually gives you, so you know what to ask.

Related questions

Is it worth repairing an old hearing aid?

Often, yes. If the fault is a single part, the device still suits your hearing and you are happy with it, a repair usually makes more sense than replacing it. It stops making sense when several things are failing at once or the parts are no longer available.

Can my current hearing aids be reprogrammed if my hearing has changed?

Usually, up to a point. Most digital hearing aids can be adjusted as your hearing shifts. If your hearing has changed beyond the range the device was built for, no amount of reprogramming will close the gap, and that is a genuine reason to replace.

Should I get my hearing checked before buying replacement hearing aids?

Yes. New hearing aids should be fit to your hearing as it is now, not as it was when you bought the last pair. Schmidt's offers free hearing screenings in Stuart. Any sudden change, change in one ear, pain, drainage or dizziness should go to a doctor first.

Do I have to replace both hearing aids if only one is failing?

Not always. If one aid has a fault that can be repaired, repairing it is often the sensible choice. If both are old and you are replacing for better technology or a change in your hearing, replacing them as a pair usually makes more sense. Ask before you decide.

The short version

  • Rule out cleaning, a new dome or wax guard, and reprogramming first.
  • Repairs piling up and scarce parts are the clearest signs to replace.
  • Hearing that has moved past what the aid can be programmed for is a real reason.
  • Wanting Bluetooth streaming or rechargeable batteries is a fair reason too.
  • Sudden changes, pain, drainage or dizziness are for a doctor, not a new device.

Not sure if yours need repair or replacing? Call (772) 286-4327 and bring them in, any brand. Call (772) 286-4327 · Hearing aid repairs and service →

Keep reading

Related guides

Hearing · 6 min read

What Florida's 30-day hearing aid trial actually gives you

What Florida law guarantees on a hearing aid trial, what a seller may keep, and what to ask first.

Read the guide →

Visit Schmidt’s

Address
Schmidt's Optical & Hearing
2341 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart Centre
Stuart, FL 34994
Serving Stuart and all of Martin County, from Palm City to Jensen Beach and Hobe Sound.
Hours
Mon–Fri 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Phone
Optical (772) 283-2622
Hearing (772) 286-4327

Most major vision plans are accepted for frames and lenses. Bring your card and we will verify your benefit before anything is ordered.

Schmidt's Optical & Hearing storefront at 2341 SE Federal Hwy, Stuart Centre, Stuart FL
Site Designed and Developed by Trusted Marketing, LLC (opens in a new tab)
Call Get directions (opens in a new tab)